A Guide to How CMO Recruiters & Executive Search Works

Picture of Casey Slaughter Stanton
Casey Slaughter Stanton

Founder and CEO
CMOx®, The Fractional CMO Company

When it comes to recruiting an exceptional Chief Marketing Officer (CMO), conventional recruiting methods aren’t likely to yield top tier marketing executives. C-suite-level executives are rarely looking for a job—instead, they allow the jobs to come to them. That’s why marketing executive search is the best method for recruiting the most qualified marketing professionals and fractional CMOs

The best executive search firms know what to look for in qualified CMO candidates and how to bridge the gap between your ideal candidate and your company. In the guide below, we’ll discuss what to look for in an exceptional CMO and how a marketing executive search firm locates and recruits them. 

Is your company in need of strong marketing leadership? CMOx not only knows what it takes to be an exceptional marketing executive, we’re also an executive search firm with connections across the industry. Our team specializes in developing and recruiting part-time CMOs for businesses who may not need a full-time executive. Contact us today to learn how we can help you find the right fractional CMO for your business.

Key Takeaways

  • Businesses can use CMO executive search services to find the best-fit marketing executive for their needs.
  • An executive search firm can identify and vet qualified candidates for their clients.
  • CMO recruiters and headhunters differ from executive search companies as the former find a large pool of candidates instead of narrowing their focus on highly-qualified individuals.

The Role of a Chief Marketing Officer

A Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) is a pivotal member of a company’s leadership team, tasked with developing and implementing a wide-reaching marketing strategy that propels business growth and revenue. The CMO leads the marketing team, oversees marketing campaigns, and ensures that the company’s brand is consistently represented across all marketing channels. 

To be successful, a CMO must have a profound understanding of the company’s target audience, industry trends, and marketing best practices. Additionally, they need to be adept at analyzing data, making informed decisions, and communicating effectively with the rest of the leadership team. A CMO’s role is not just about marketing; it’s about driving the overall business strategy through innovative and effective marketing initiatives.

CMO Executive Search

CMO executive search is a little different than an executive search for other c-suite roles. An effective CMO must have a number of nuanced soft skills and industry-specific knowledge. This means your executive search firm must understand these qualifications, as well. Modern marketing requires CMOs to adapt to changing consumer needs and technology, implementing innovative strategies that drive ROI and enhance the customer experience.

In these cases, it’s best to look for an executive search firm specializing in recruiting marketing executives. That way, you can be sure the firm understands your needs and can effectively identify the best candidates.

How Do You Recruit a CMO?

The best way to recruit a CMO is through executive search. Chief marketing officers established in their roles are unlikely to respond to a job posting, but may consider coming to your company for the right incentives. An marketing executive recruiters can both locate qualified CMO candidates and explain to them the advantages of becoming the marketing leader for your business. 

This process is also typically more efficient than contingency recruiting, especially when it comes to executive roles.

When To Rely On A CMO Executive Search Firm

Using a CMO executive search firm during the recruiting process is particularly beneficial when your company needs to fill the role quickly or when the position requires a specific set of skills and industry experience that are difficult to find. These firms have access to an extensive network of highly qualified candidates and can provide valuable insights into market trends, compensation benchmarks, and candidate expectations. 

Additionally, a search firm takes on the time-consuming tasks of sourcing, screening, and vetting candidates, allowing your team to focus on core business operations. By partnering with a search firm, you benefit from their expertise in matching the right talent with your company’s unique needs, reducing the risk of a costly hiring mistake and ensuring a more strategic, targeted approach to finding your next CMO.

CMO Recruitment Needs & Requirements

When recruiting a CMO, it’s essential to identify your business’s marketing objectives first. You can then use those goals to develop requirements to find the right marketing leader for your business. 

Unlike other c-suite employees, the role of a CMO is highly variable and often overlaps with the responsibilities of other executives. For instance, a CMO and CEO may work together when developing marketing and business strategies because those two things need to align in order for the business to succeed. 

Though most of a CMO’s desired qualifications will be unique to your company, there are a few things every CMO should have, including: 

  • Current and comprehensive industry knowledge
  • Experience with your company’s products or services
  • Insight into your targeted market or customer base
  • Leadership skills to guide your marketing team

This means your chosen CMO should have experience in your niche industry—or at least, be interested in learning quickly.

Attracting & Vetting Qualified Candidates

Reaching out to qualified candidates is a key part of a CMO executive search. During this process, it’s vital to learn as much as possible about each candidate while sharing how changing roles would benefit them. 

Few CMOs are interested in making a lateral move—an executive recruitment firm’s first conversation with each candidate should include why your company is a better fit. This may include a higher salary, more benefits, or a better company culture.

This conversation is also a way to vet potential candidates. The search firm’s consultants will confirm each marketing professional’s qualifications to ensure they’re a good fit for your company.

The Process of CMO Executive Search

Any CMO executive search should start by forming a partnership with a CMO executive search firm. These firms specialize in hiring full-time CMOs, and possibly also part-time and interim CMOs. Their recruiters have a deep understanding of the unique qualifications an effective CMO must have. 

After you’ve chosen an executive search firm, they’ll follow a standardized process to identify and contact qualified candidates: 

  1. Finalize qualifications so they know what skills and experience your CMO should have
  2. Create a targeted search to find top marketing talent within a geographic area
  3. Contact each candidate to evaluate their qualifications and gauge their interest
  4. Narrow down the candidate pool to a shortlist
  5. Facilitate interviews, communicate with candidates, and support the onboarding process

How Much Does it Cost to Hire a CMO?

When you hire an executive search firm to help you hire a CMO, be prepared to pay the firm approximately 35% of a CMO’s annual salary—typically between $100,000 and $300,000. 

Of course, executive search firms only get paid once, after they’ve helped you onboard your chosen candidate. That means they’re deeply invested in providing you with the most qualified options.

CMO Recruiters vs Headhunters vs Executive Search

Marketing recruiters, headhunters, and executive search firms—what’s the difference? All of them can identify and recommend CMO candidates.

However, CMO executive recruiters and headhunters tend to focus on finding a large pool of candidates that may or may not be qualified leaders. Additionally, marketing executive headhunters work for the candidates, not the companies, so it’s in the headhunters’ best interest to incentivize companies to hire their clients.

Executive search firms, on the other hand, partner with companies to identify candidates that closely match their needs. They focus on candidates’ skills and accomplishments, not whether they’re actively seeking a job. With executive search, quality comes before everything else.

Why Choose CMO Executive Search Over Traditional Hiring Methods

With traditional hiring, you create a job posting, place it on job boards, and wait for candidates to apply to the position. This method is effective for lower-level positions, but is much less successful when looking for executive marketing professionals.

Non-executive employees frequently look for new jobs as a way to increase their pay or advance their career. CMOS are rarely looking for a new position—instead, they’re focused on developing their employees and ensuring their marketing strategy remains current. Executive search empowers you to recruit these candidates via networking and negotiation, ensuring whoever you choose closely matches your needs.

Summary of CMO Recruitment

Hiring an exceptional CMO with executive search begins by selecting a knowledgeable executive search firm with a proven track record in recruiting leadership. The firm will then shoulder the responsibility of identifying potential candidates, narrowing down the candidate pool to a shortlist, facilitating interviews, and supporting the onboarding process. 

If you want an executive search firm that understands what it takes to be an effective fractional CMO, CMOx is the company for you. We develop fractional CMOs every day, and we have an innate talent for identifying exceptional marketing leaders. Contact us today to learn how we can help you recruit your next part-time chief marketing officer.

Picture of Casey Slaughter Stanton

Casey Slaughter Stanton

Casey S. Stanton is a marketing strategy expert and founder of CMOx®, the Fractional CMO company. For over 10 years Casey has been leading marketing strategy for 7 and 8 figure businesses in both digital and brick-and-mortar markets.

Picture of Casey Slaughter Stanton

Casey Slaughter Stanton

Casey S. Stanton is a marketing strategy expert and founder of CMOx®, the Fractional CMO company. For over 10 years Casey has been leading marketing strategy for 7 and 8 figure businesses in both digital and brick-and-mortar markets.

Ready to Become an In-Demand Fractional CMO?

Take the first step to success and choose a CMO

Schedule a Call

We’ll find out what your goals are and make sure its a good fit.

See Your Marketing Map

Your fractional CMO will create a comprehensive Functional Marketing® Framework map with the insight they glean in the first 30 days working with you.

Execute in 60 days

Your fractional CMO will build and guide your team to execute on the map for the next 60 days. They’ll provide an updated plan and execute every 90 days thereafter.

Now just let us know where to send the free report...

  • Hidden
  • Hidden
  • Hidden
  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Now just let us know where to send your copy...

First Name*
Last Name*
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
What is your annual revenue?*
How soon are you looking to hire?*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Now just let us know where to send your copy...

Name*
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
What is your current role?*
What is your current revenue as a marketer?*
Where are you in your Fractional CMO journey?*

TCPA
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Now just let us know where to send your copy...

First Name*
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
Hidden
What is your current role?*
What is your current revenue as a marketer?*
Where are you in your Fractional CMO journey?*

TCPA
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE RESOURCE

Don’t Miss These Important KPIs that determine your company’s health.

Success might be slipping through your grasp right in front of you without you knowing. Learn about readily available data that if used properly can lead to exponential growth.